This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Not legal advice. Details.
The bankruptcy claims secondary market exists because creditors want liquidity and investors want yield. If you're considering buying claims, understand the mechanics, risks, and strategies for building a profitable claims portfolio. A claims-trading desk without a template library is a slow claims-trading desk. LawDepot's assignment and release templates cover the structural paperwork; Rule 3001(e) disclosures go on top with counsel.
Who Buys Bankruptcy Claims?
Bankruptcy claim buyers fall into several categories:
- Hedge funds and distressed debt investors: Buy large claim portfolios, hold for recovery
- Claims trading firms: Buy and sell claims quickly, arbitrage pricing inefficiencies
- Specialized claim funds: Target specific case types or industries
- Individual investors: Buy smaller claims, often for specific cases they follow
Step 1: Find Available Claims
Claims don't trade on a centralized exchange. Finding them requires:
Claims Trading Platforms
Some platforms aggregate available claims:
- SecondMarket (acquired by Nasdaq) – historical platform, now limited
- Various law firm bulletin boards – smaller, case-specific listings
- Direct creditor outreach – contacting claim holders directly
PACER Database Searches
The federal bankruptcy PACER system is free. Search for cases matching your investment thesis (e.g., large Chapter 11 filings, specific industries). Identify the trustee and contact them about available claims.
Step 2: Conduct Due Diligence
Before committing capital, investigate thoroughly:
Review Bankruptcy Schedules
The debtor files detailed schedules of assets and liabilities. Review these to understand:
- Total assets and their estimated value
- Total liabilities and number of claimants
- Whether any assets are already subject to liens (reducing available funds)
Assess Case Status
Where is the case in the process?
- Early stage (still identifying assets) → higher risk, lower prices
- Liquidation in progress (assets being sold) → better visibility, higher prices
- Near resolution (distributions planned) → clearer recovery timeline
Analyze the Claim Type and Priority
What claim are you buying? Secured claims recover more reliably. Priority unsecured claims come next. General unsecured claims are riskier. Calculate your expected recovery rate based on these priorities and estate size.
Check for Disputes or Objections
Are there any motions to deny or reduce claims? Any litigation? Any creditor disputes? These add risk and extend timelines. Factor these into your valuation.
Step 3: Negotiate Price
Once you've identified a claim worth buying, negotiate the purchase price. Sellers typically want high prices (they're optimistic). Buyers want low prices (conservative). The actual trade happens somewhere in between.
Key negotiation tactics:
- Start with a conservative valuation (15–30% below what you'd ultimately pay)
- Point out any risks or uncertainties in the case
- Highlight the time value of money (how long recovery will take)
- Offer to close quickly if it significantly improves the terms
Step 4: Execute the Purchase Agreement
A claims purchase agreement should specify:
- The exact claim amount and priority
- The purchase price and payment terms
- Representations and warranties from the seller (e.g., "claim is valid," "no other claims against this asset")
- Assignment mechanism (how the claim gets transferred to you)
- Indemnification if the claim is later challenged
Use a template agreement and have a lawyer review it. Claim sales happen quickly; don't skip legal review.
Step 5: File Assignment in Court
Once you've purchased a claim, you need to formally notify the court. File an "assignment of claim" (requirements vary by court) to register yourself as the new owner. This ensures you receive distributions instead of the original creditor.
Step 6: Monitor and Manage the Portfolio
Track distributions, case progress, and potential risks. Most claim holders receive periodic distributions over months or years. Maintain your court filings and contact information to ensure you don't miss notices.
Risk Mitigation Strategies
Portfolio Diversification
Don't put all your capital into one claim or one case. Spread across multiple cases, industries, and case stages.
Ladder Recovery Timelines
Buy some claims that resolve in months, others that take years. This smooths cash flow and reduces timing risk.
Mix Priorities
Buy some high-priority claims (lower yield, lower risk) and some lower-priority claims (higher yield, higher risk). Balance risk and reward.